Oscar nominee Rose Byrne is basically the reigning queen of chaotic comedy (Bridesmaids, anyone?), and seeing her cut loose on stage alongside Tony-winning powerhouse Kelli O’Hara from The Gilded Age is the high-society fever dream we all needed. This Noël Coward revival turns into a total champagne-fueled disaster when these two besties realize they’ve both slept with the same suave Frenchman—who happens to be played by Mark Consuelos (yes, Kelly Ripa’s husband!) making his big Broadway debut.